@blcktofu I am not sure #livecoding is #political. It is true that most live coding environments are #opensource but the the live coding manifesto for example does not mention opensource anywhere... However, many (but not all though) practitioners are politically oriented in their choice for opensource and thus I see why you are making the association between the two.... https://toplap.org/wiki/ManifestoDraft
@celesteh
@torrejuseppe thank you. My intention is not to take this discussion to the pragmatic side, of finding solutions, but as an outsider i was curious if the #livecode community also sees it as an issue or a contradiction and if so, how is being addressed.
@celesteh @blcktofu yes I am new too to the live coding sphere and yet the affinity between FLOOS or opensource (which I support) and live coding appears present. Still to reconnect to the initial post in this thread I do not see any explicit contradiction in doing live coding and using proprietary software as the intent of live coding are more explicitly directed towards live performance issues.
A great contradiction I found thanks to this thread is instead that of Github, famous for hosting thousands of opensource projects and not being opensource itself! Now that is a contradiction! I moved all my stuff to Gitlab (great!) Thanks :)
@torrejuseppe @celesteh @blcktofu I think one way to think about it is not so much in terms of political realm, but whether or not there can be a universal inflection point in cognitive dissonance when dogfooding free and open source software practices, and free culture in general. When I researched the issue, it's clear that no practitioners agree on where to draw the line with cultural and software freedom.
Thank you @torrejuseppe tge think is that o believe there is something inherently political about it, although i cannot pin-point them. And i find that some of the exciting ( unspoken) ethos is bypassed when live coding events rely heavily on not only proprietary software but big corporation to publish the outcomes and handle communication.